Note: You are reading this message either because you did not load our stylesheets, or you are not using a standards-compliant browser. Please consider using one of these browsers to view this web site: Firefox, Opera, Internet Explorer, or Safari (Mac).

Silas Notes

Computers in movies also warrant suspended disbelief

Posted by Rhea on January 9, 2007

Computers in movies also warrant suspended disbelief Some time ago, I watched Jack Bauer from the TV series “24″ use his cellphone camera to magnify a serial number on a jacket 200 feet away. That said, I was also willing to suspend disbelief that his PDA can download an abandoned building’s schematics in a matter of seconds. (and that they were able to retrieve that schematic diagram in the first place!)

Would watching a show like “24″ where computers are standard props have any effect on the way we perceive technology and usability? Jakob Nielsen thinks they might. Could it potentially explain why we, the populace, expect to understand any interface we sit in front of and rant if we can’t figure it out? Would it explain why we have a hankering for everything voice activated?

In his chuckle-inducing article “Usability in the Movies — Top 10 Bloopers ” he summarizes that “User interfaces in film are more exciting than they are realistic, and heroes have far too easy a time using foreign systems. ” Here are some of my favorites:

1) “This is Unix, It’s easy.” Enough said. :)

2) “You’ve Got Mail” is always good news. Wading through hundreds of emails after getting back from holiday break makes these three words cause for trepidation. (”Nooo! I still have 243 unread emails!”)

3) “Big fonts.Another website observed that they seem to be an inch high. Imagine glaring “Yes” and “No” buttons and fullscreen “Enter Password” screens.

Read all 10 bloopers on UseIt.com>>

  1. I forgot to mention that my favorite technology improbability comes from The Matrix. In the scene right after Neo’s classic backbend against the bullets, Trinity asks for a download of a helicopter manual into her brain.

    I could’ve used a calculus download for my college math class.

    Posted by Rhea Jan 09
  2. Mine is War Games. The whole premise that a kid could hack NORAD. You have to love the old skool modem though. One where you have to physically put the phone handset onto a piece of your computer, classic.

    Posted by Jacob Jan 09
  3. Jack Bauer is like MacGeyver — he has mad skills! What a timely post — when 24 is starting in just a few days!

    Posted by Fedor Jan 10
  4. My favorite was always Enemy of the State, where computers in 1999 can take an image from a clothing store video camera, “magnify” it, “sharpen” it, and then ROTATE IT IN 3D to see the subject’s face more clearly. I can’t even count the number of logical flaws in that statement.

    Posted by Doug Nelson Jan 11

Leave a comment